The profit you imagine is not the profit you get
Here's the trap almost every new seller falls into: cost is $12, you sell it for $30, so obviously you made $18. Except the marketplace took 15% off the top ($4.50), shipping ran $4, you spent $3 on ads to get the sale, and roughly 8% of orders like this one come back as returns — which, spread across every sale, quietly costs you another $2.40 on average. What actually lands in your account is closer to $4.10, not $18.
That $30 sale, in full
- $4.10 real profit — a 13.7% margin, not the 60% it looked like on paper
- Marketplace fee $4.50 · Shipping $4 · Ads $3 · Returns cost ~$2.40 spread across every sale
- Break-even price on this cost structure: about $24.68
- Selling below that isn't a discount — it's a loss
Three things worth knowing before you set a price
Fees are a percentage of price, not of profit
A 15% marketplace fee sounds small until you realize it comes off the top, before your cost is even subtracted. On a low-margin product, that 15% can be the difference between a solid profit and losing money on every order — which is exactly what the break-even price and minimum profitable price tools are built to catch before you list.
Ads only make sense below your break-even ROAS
Every seller has heard "aim for a 4x ROAS" as a rule of thumb, but the right number depends entirely on your margin. A product with fat margins can profitably run ads at a 2x ROAS. A thin-margin product might need 6x just to break even. There's no universal target — there's only your break-even ROAS.
Returns are a cost even when the item wasn't defective
An 8% return rate doesn't mean 8% of your profit disappears — it means every single sale carries a small, averaged-out cost, because you don't know in advance which ones will come back. Building that into your per-sale math, instead of being surprised by it monthly, is the difference between pricing confidently and guessing.
What these tools assume
Marketplace fee presets (Amazon, eBay, Etsy) are typical published rates for most categories — your actual fee can vary by category, account type and fulfillment method, so always sanity-check against your own seller dashboard. Return-cost math assumes you don't recover the product cost or the marketplace fee on a returned order, which is the conservative (safe) assumption for most categories.
Every field is editable and nothing here is financial advice — these are the same formulas a good spreadsheet would run, just without you having to build the spreadsheet.